Random Quote

A university is what a college becomes when the faculty loses interest in students.
---- John Ciardi

Just because your voice reaches halfway around the world doesn't mean you are wiser than when it reached only to the end of the bar.
---- Edward R. Murrow

Hanging is too good for a man who makes puns; he should be drawn and quoted.
---- Fred Allen

To have another language is to possess a second soul.
---- Charlemagne

I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.
---- Thomas A. Edison

Always be wary of any helpful item that weighs less than its operating manual.
---- Terry Pratchett

Learning is not attained by chance, it must be sought for with ardor and attended to with diligence.
---- Abigail Adams (1744 - 1818)

I have never met a man so ignorant that I couldn't learn something from him.
---- Galileo Galilei

Man invented language to satisfy his deep need to complain.
---- Lily Tomlin

Isn't it interesting that the same people who laugh at science fiction listen to weather forecasts and economists?"
---- Kelvin Throop III

A magician pulls rabbits out of hats. An experimental psychologist pulls habits out of rats.
---- anonymous

it's probably not a good idea to underestimate my ability to make an ass out of myself—just when I seem to have it under control, I'll turn around and surprise you.
---- Tenser said the Tensor

Books to the ceiling,
Books to the sky,
My pile of books is a mile high.
How I love them! How I need them!
I'll have a long beard by the time I read them.
---- Arnold Lobel

As an adolescent I aspired to lasting fame, I craved factual certainty, and I thirsted for a meaningful vision of human life - so I became a scientist. This is like becoming an archbishop so you can meet girls.
---- M. Cartmill

If the English language made any sense, a catastrophe would be an apostrophe with fur.
---- Doug Larson

Technology will not replace teachers...teachers who use technology will
probably replace teachers who do not.
---- Ray Clifford

To get something done, a committee should consist of no more than three men, two of whom are absent.
---- Robert Copeland

Education's purpose is to replace an empty mind with an open one.
---- Malcom Forbes

As soon as I buy the moose head, I have to go pick up some KY jelly.
---- Mary Roninette Kowal

Any man whose errors take ten years to correct is quite a man.
---- J. Robert Oppenheimer

The important thing is not to stop questioning.
---- Albert Einstein

Those who know nothing of foreign languages, knows nothing of their own.”
---- Johann Wolfgang Von Goethe (1749 -1832)

Sleep is a symptom of caffeine deprivation.
---- Author Unknown

Human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe.
---- H. G. Wells

Drink coffee! Do stupid things faster!
---- unknown

subscribe to RSS feed
 Thursday November 11 2004

Not an Academic

I have come to the realization that I am not an academican. I thought it would be fun to get published someday; wriiting books or journal articles. However I have come to the realization that I truly dislike the rigidity of academic prose especially the need to write in overly wordy, pedantic sentences when there are much clearer easier ways to express your thoughts. But of course if you write like that no-one takes you seriously. The more cryptic and enigmatic your style the better a writer or researcher you are. I don’t buy it.

Additionally spending all this time writing essays has taken the pleasure out of reading authors l like such as, David Nunan, Joy M. Reid, & H. Douglas Brown to name but a few. Additionally this semester I feel that the quality of my teaching and lesson planning is suffering due ot a severe case of burn-out. I know that my writing is not up to the quality that it should be either, in fact it feels to me like this entire semester has been one academic and professional disaster.  It even got to the point where I considered quitting the M.A. altogether, but I decided against that.


At this point I am debating about whether to do the dissertation option, which will take one more year, or take two more courses and be done with everything next June. I know the coursework is the easy road out - something I generally abhor taking, but I’m just so tired of studying and full-time work and a family. Everything suffers and doesn’t get the attention it deservers especially my daughter who is only 33 months old.

Doing the dissertation has many advantages including being the more traditional route of completing masters level study. I also feel that having done the degree by distance, doing the dissertation will add value since some employers may look down on distance education (Taiwan does not recognize distance degrees) though I think that is a foolish attitude. Distance study is by far more difficult than attending class. There is a lot of self-discipline and motivation involved and also the difficulty of getting help with hard to understand concepts and terminology.

Another advantage of doing the dissertation is that I do find the ideas behind my research proposal genuinely interesting and of value to the teaching community at whole. I"m sure the experience of collecting, collating, and analyzing the data will bring a new dimension of understanding to further reading I do in the field.

Perhaps this semester has been difficult because it’s the end 2.5 years of course work and far too much of the readings have had little practicle usage in the classroom. Research methods is all about doing research and has no practical implications in my day to day teaching - though of course it is incredibly important and useful with regards to the dissertation option. Pragmatics on the other hand had far less practicle usage than one would expect (Sorry David - I know pragmatics is your specialty) and was very different from what I expected both on the part of the course summary and my understanding of what pragmatics entails. In the end this course was more about discourse analysis than pragmatics - a disappointment to say the least.

On friday I submit my essays and then I have some time before I must decide whether to take course work or do the dissertation. Who knows maybe I’ll feel better about it after I get some rest and can start studying Korean in December - and spend a little less time staring at this bloody computer screen.


Sean. inscribed these words of wisdom on Thursday Nov 11, 2004 at 12:24 AM
general_linguistic_study | Dissertation |

Picture of john

john wrote 122 words  on  Thursday Nov 11, 2004  at  02:21 AM Korea (South)

Blinger,

Feeling your pain - been there, done that, and man is it great on the other side. Are you planning on teaching in Taiwan, or just want to keep the option open? My life has just got back to some semblance of order (finished my MA in June - just got the paper in Sept). My 31 month-old son is happy to see me home from the job I got due to getting that paper.

Hope you get the rest and rejuvination you need to get through your coursework. Taiwan my not recognize what you have, but mony other places do - including Canada when/if you decide to return (for some reason I think you’re Canadian - T/F!?!?).

Enjoy your break.

Picture of David (TEFL Smiler)

David (TEFL Smiler) wrote 309 words  on  Thursday Nov 11, 2004  at  02:43 AM Great Britain (UK)

Re your comments on the typical style of academic writing: “Hear, hear!” I totally agree. I feel, though, that much of the stuff written nowadays is easier to decipher than a lot of the prose written in the 1970s, for instance. I doubt that anyone’s expecting you to write like that!

Re distance study and burn-out: I’ve never tried it, but I can imagine that it must take a lot out of you. So I can say that you have my respect. I’m sure it’ll come good in the end. If you’ve had the strength and the will-power to make it this far, then it’ll be OK. I think your courses this semester have been particularly harrowing, so it’s no surprise that your body and mind will be reacting badly towards them.

Re pragmatics: I feel partly responsible here, having recommended the topic. Knowing now what you’ve had to cover on this course, I feel particularly bad for you. It isn’t the pragmatics I know and love. Rather than studying the main theories and ideas in the area, you’ve had to read semi-significant texts by bit-part players with very few original thoughts between them. And your essay questions have been nonsense. They’ve been attempts to make the students make pragmatics relevant to them in a pointless and quite frankly annoying manner. But that’s the thing so often about university courses: they withhold the detailed information about the weekly content of a course until you’re enrolled. On the course description, it looked like it would be fabulous, I thought. The moment I saw the reading list, though, the alarm bells started to ring.

My advice - although I’d understand you not listening to me! - would be to do all you can to keep your options open, as you never know what you might want to do in the future.

Picture of Scott Sommers

Scott Sommers wrote 106 words  on  Thursday Nov 11, 2004  at  10:39 AM Taiwan

I don’t know if you were ever in the army, but it’s a similar experience. At first, they make you run and run and run, and it’s terrible. But eventually, your conditioning improves so much that what what used to be almost impossible become relatively easy. The moral of this is that if you keep writing in academic style everyday until your hands fall off, even if you think your style is getting worse and worse, eventually it will become effortless for you and you’ll be able to write that way with ease.

On the other hand, maybe you don’t want to aquire this valuable skill.

Sean.

Sean. wrote 179 words  on  Friday Nov 12, 2004  at  12:43 AM Korea (South)

John,
Thanks for the encouragement. I’m not planning on going to Taiwan, I just listed it as one place that doesn’t recognize distance degrees. I am aware that Canada recognizes them as I did research befoe deciding on doing a distance degree.

David,
Yes it is easier to read for the most part but some of it can still be unnecessarily convoluted and cryptic. Don’t feel responsible. You raised the interest for me - it’s not your fault that I didn’t enjoy it or that the course didn’t live up to what it advertised.

Scott,
I’ve heard the army analogy before and I agree that it is true. But I dont’ see any need for academics to write in the style that they do. Why can’t everyone write in a clear easy to understand style. That doesn’t mean using simple vocabulary - just avoiding overly long and convoluted sentences that require 2-3 or sometimes more read throughs to fully understand.

I don’t consider writing in an academic style to be a valuable skill but rather an unfortunatly necessary evil.

Picture of yuhuachen

yuhuachen wrote 101 words  on  Friday Nov 12, 2004  at  04:33 PM Australia

Hi Blinger,
Well, as for my experience, I do feel taking course work is a much better choice. I don’t mean that you will feel a lot more easier if u do course work (cuz you will still have lots of things to do)...As for my opinion, i think spending time writing something you want to write about is far more interesting!! I was suffering doing my SLA very theoretical paper, which almost killed my interest toward SLA~
As for Taiwan and distance learning, it really depends on where u want to teach and what city you wanna go…

good luck

Picture of HK Teacher

HK Teacher wrote 71 words  on  Saturday Nov 13, 2004  at  07:52 PM Hong Kong

I sympathise with your thoughts about academic writing. I was told (half seriously) that the title of my dissertation should have a colon in it to make it ‘more academic’!

In the end, I enjoyed the sense of accomplishment of finishing a dissertation, even though only 2 or 3 people will ever read it. It also took alot out of me, and I could quite understand if someone took another option.

Picture of Tim Nall

Tim Nall wrote 86 words  on  Sunday Nov 14, 2004  at  08:22 PM United States

Hmmmmm. I don’t find academic writing (outside of Freire, the Great Prose Mobius Strip) that hard to understand. Boring from time to time, of course, but not at all indecipherable. Perhaps you and I are reading different things? But if it is hard to understand, and assuming the writer is not from a culture with notably different conventions than the ones used in English, then I would lay the blame squarely on the writer. I hope they aren’t teaching writing classes, or writing books about writing. grin

Picture of Dan

Dan wrote 155 words  on  Monday Nov 15, 2004  at  05:45 PM Japan

I can empathize with your situation. I started a distance MA in Japanese and am involved in a similar balancing act between family, work, and a degree program. I have a choice between an annotated translation or a paper. To be honest translation bores me to death. That is why I am trying to learn more Japanese, so I can read originals. Not only that, but I have found a topic that I’m really interested in and has a strong relationship with the department that I am in now. I can use the work that I do in researching this paper as a springboard for other similar research.

I guess my point is that if you choose a topic that has more connections with you and your life after the degree program, maybe that would help. Otherwise, take the classes, but gut it out and finish. My guess is that you’ll be happy you did.

Picture of Maestra

Maestra wrote 41 words  on  Tuesday Nov 16, 2004  at  07:28 PM United States

Lie down. Beathe deeply several times. Pick a great mantra like: END. Smile. Then think of your finished paper and smile again. Relax. Picture that paper. Picture that sheepskin on your wall. Relax. Smile. Breathe deeply.
Now go get ‘em, Tiger!

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Members





Auto-login on future visits
Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password? |  Register

Polling Station

Are you Attending KOTESOL 2008?
pencil

Twitter Updates

    Buy me a Coffee